In December 1734, Johann Lorenz von Mosheim turned down a job at a university that had barely begun to teach. Gerlach Adolph von Münchhausen, the Hanoverian official building it, wanted the celebrated theologian for Göttingen. Mosheim had good reasons to stay in Helmstedt. He was abbot of two monasteries, oversaw schools, and worried that if he left, his students would scatter and townspeople would lose their livelihoods. He laid out his reasons at length.

When Münchhausen answered in early January, he admitted he had objections but could see little point in making them. Instead, he asked Mosheim to keep writing, pass along what he heard, and suggest someone to lead the theology faculty. He thought some things about the fledgling university were “better judged by the ears than by the eyes.” Mosheim was already offering detailed assessments of possible hires and volunteered to approach two theologians he knew well. He went on to recommend scholars and help persuade some to come. In 1747 he came himself, taking up a post created for him as the university’s chancellor. What Münchhausen saw in the man who turned him down, it seems, was a colleague he could work with right away. Mosheim’s recommendations · Recruitment study · Mosheim’s appointment

Hanover had reasons to want a university well before it had professors. Its students could go elsewhere for an education; their money went with them. A university of its own could keep that spending at home, draw students from other territories, and train lawyers for public service. Its ruler, George II, was also king of Great Britain. The two states shared a monarch, and Hanover’s officials had a channel to London. That gave Göttingen an opening to recruit across the Channel. Founding history · University chronology

Münchhausen had studied law at Halle, the Prussian university he hoped to rival. He remembered how Halle and Jena gave students a fresh choice of courses every semester. Parents and students, he later told Gebauer, could hardly be forced to make do with whatever a faculty offered. He remembered something else about Halle: apart from the eminent jurist Samuel Stryk, he thought its professors below the rank of full professor had done more good than the men with chairs. He knew of cases where senior academics tried to hold them back. Münchhausen’s account

In a letter of March 16, 1736, Münchhausen was planning the inauguration. He told a correspondent at Hanover’s German Chancery in London that he wanted to draw English gentlemen to Göttingen. They would be “just as well off as in Holland,” where they were spending freely. As Johanna Oehler’s research shows, the university was already circulating a prospectus through the German Chancery in London. The letter measures success in something a government could count: students choosing Göttingen and paying for their stay there.

The trouble was getting teachers worth traveling for. Münchhausen’s first plan called for famous scholars already holding chairs. His short list put Christoph Matthäus Pfaff of Tübingen and Johann Jakob Rambach of Giessen alongside Mosheim. Prussia barred its professors from accepting outside offers; Saxony followed its example, and other rulers resisted losing their own scholars. Münchhausen asked George II for more money to recruit eminent professors. The king refused. More money could sweeten an offer. It could hardly make a rival ruler release a professor. Anne Saada and Sébastien Schick’s study of the correspondence

By July 12, 1739, Münchhausen was defending a different plan to Georg Christian Gebauer, Göttingen’s first full professor of law. Gebauer doubted the wisdom of bringing in more junior professors. Münchhausen thought competition could do harm as well as good, but he wanted Göttingen to be “a nursery” from which every faculty could draw future full professors. Start promising scholars as extraordinary professors: they could teach and collect course fees without drawing a fixed university salary. Choose carefully, he told Gebauer, and give them no expectation of succeeding to a chair. Saada and Schick counted 64 full professors appointed from 1734 through 1763. Only 10 had already held that rank before coming to Göttingen. In the first generation of hires, some came from junior professorships and others from jobs as schoolteachers, pastors, and tutors. Letter to Gebauer · Appointment figures

Whose judgment could substitute for a title? Münchhausen compared reports from people he trusted, called candidates in, and kept the decision with Hanover’s council rather than the faculties. In a June 1739 postscript to Gebauer, he asked about a Leipzig lecturer named Abraham Gotthelf Kästner who had written several disputations. Kästner eventually became an extraordinary professor in Leipzig. In 1756 he took a full chair in mathematics and physics at Göttingen. Münchhausen had asked about him seventeen years earlier.

Some hires changed what could be studied in Göttingen within a few years. The physician Albrecht von Haller arrived in 1736 to teach anatomy, surgery, and botany. He established an anatomical theater and a botanical garden, collecting plants from the Alps and the Harz Mountains. In 1751 he became the first president of Göttingen’s new scientific society. Hiring gave a scholar a place to work; Haller built places where others could work as well. University records on Haller · History of the garden · History of the society

Nearly two centuries later, Max Born studied particle collisions at Göttingen and worked out how to use a quantum wave function to predict the probabilities of different outcomes. That 1926 work earned him a share of the 1954 Nobel Prize in Physics. Later generations built the setting for that work: Felix Klein worked with Prussia’s science administration to build Göttingen into a center for mathematics and the sciences, and Born, Werner Heisenberg, and Pascual Jordan developed quantum mechanics together there. The university gave them a place to work; the physics was theirs. Göttingen’s history of physics

Another capable minister would probably have opened a Hanoverian university, put law near its center, and tried to attract British students. The crown’s backing and the case for keeping students and their money in Hanover were already there. The decision that seems most distinctly Münchhausen’s was to make finding and developing future professors a standing practice. The shortage made junior hires attractive; it took judgment to learn whose recommendations to trust and patience to see who grew into a chair. You can see that judgment before he ever explained it to Gebauer: a man says no, and Münchhausen asks what he knows.

Quotations from the correspondence are translated into English from Emil Franz Rössler’s 1855 edition. Image: Rössler, p. 152, Göttingen State and University Library (CC BY 4.0).